Head to Head
| Major League Rugby | 2021/06/26 20:30 | Toronto Arrows v New York | W | 24-31 |
| Major League Rugby | 2021/04/25 18:00 | New York v Toronto Arrows | L | 12-53 |
| Major League Rugby | 2019/03/15 23:00 | New York v Toronto Arrows | W | 24-21 |
Home History
| Major League Rugby | 2022/03/20 00:00 | NOLA Gold v New York | W | 19-30 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/03/13 19:00 | New York v San Diego Legion | W | 26-23 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/03/06 20:00 | New York v New England Free Jacks | L | 29-38 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/27 01:00 | Dallas Jackals v New York | W | 5-41 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/19 20:00 | RFC Los Angeles v New York | W | 31-36 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/13 01:00 | Houston Sabercats v New York | W | 7-10 |
| Major League Rugby | 2021/07/25 00:00 | RFC Los Angeles v New York | L | 10-9 |
| Major League Rugby | 2021/07/17 18:00 | New York v NOLA Gold | L | 32-35 |
Away History
| Major League Rugby | 2022/03/19 20:30 | Utah Warriors v Toronto Arrows | W | 24-27 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/03/12 21:30 | New England Free Jacks v Toronto Arrows | L | 21-15 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/26 21:00 | Old Glory DC v Toronto Arrows | W | 5-29 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/19 21:00 | NOLA Gold v Toronto Arrows | W | 23-24 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/12 03:00 | Toronto Arrows v LA Giltinis | L | 16-31 |
| Major League Rugby | 2022/02/07 03:00 | Seattle Seawolves v Toronto Arrows | L | 21-8 |
| Major League Rugby | 2021/07/11 16:00 | Toronto Arrows v New England Free Jacks | L | 17-28 |
| Major League Rugby | 2021/07/04 22:00 | Toronto Arrows v Old Glory DC | W | 34-28 |